Last week, we discussed the case of a 17-year-old author who fell victim to yet another defunct publisher. His mother didn’t know if she could trust another one. And, her concerns were completely valid! Investing hundreds to thousands of dollars to get your book published, only to lose everything months or years later, including your files, is a tragedy for any author. Authors of traditionally published books are also at risk. Imagine spending a year or two, or more, working with a publisher only to have them shut their doors, leaving you in a lurch, and with no book for sale.
While Googling the name of a publisher before plunking down any cash is always a good thing, the sad fact is that most authors don’t do their homework because they’re so excited about getting their book on the market yesterday. While some fall for the false “you’re book is sure to be a best seller!” marketing verbiage, others think that a firm with such a pretty, professional website couldn’t possibly be at risk of failure, right?
So, today let’s look at some print on demand publishers, publishing service providers, and even a handful of traditional publishers that have gone belly up.
All Romance E-Books – “We will be unable to remit Q4 2016 commissions in full and are proposing a settlement of 10 cents on the dollar (USD) for payments received through 27 December 2016. We also request the following conditions: 1. That you consider this negotiated settlement to be ‘paid in full’. 2. That no further legal action be taken with regards to the above referenced commissions owed.” Wait…what?
America Star Books (a.k.a. PublishAmerica) – While they never officially announced they were out of business (their websites are still operating but one is now in a foreign language), they have reportedly stopped responding to authors. There are numerous complaints about unpaid royalties and their authors are in a lurch because this publisher took all rights. The authors can’t move their books to other publishers without taking a legal risk in doing so. Read Victoria Strauss’ detailed expose’ RIGHT HERE.
American Book Publishing – According to Writer Beware’s last report, they were no longer publishing, but were still selling books.
Books and Boos Press – According to their website, the owners got divorced, and had to “liquidate” their assets. That sounds odd because, if the company was actually making any money, why would they simply shut it down instead of selling it? And, honestly, with a name like that, it doesn’t surprise me that they’re out of business.
BookTango – First owned by Author Solutions. According to Michael Kozlowski, writing for GoodeReader.com, “…there was too much competition for BookTango to survive. They launched in 2012 and closed their doors in 2016.”
Booktrope – “It’s screwy, but it’s in the contract,” said Rosenfield. “My contract [stated] that should Booktrope fail and I choose to republish, it is up to [me and my team at Booktrope] to negotiate a fair settlement or [for me] to continue paying out a percentage.”
Breezeway Books – See more info. about this firm in the Llumina Press listing below. As of 12/27/22, the Breezeway Books website is gone.
Commonwealth Publications of Canada – Read about the dealings of this firm RIGHT HERE.
CrossBooks – “B&H has decided to close CrossBooks because ‘B&H simply decided to use resources to pursue other opportunities.'”
Egmont Publishing – Rob McMenemy, CEO of Egmont Publishing International, said the U.S. business, ultimately, “does not fit with the company’s strategy, as it has not been able to become a market leader in the States.” He added that Egmont was “hoping to succeed with selling the business, unfortunately this has turned out not to be possible.”
Five Star Publishing – The parent company, Thorndike Press, is closing this imprint that publishes Westerns. Thorndike Press is going to focus on Large Print titles.
Gardenia Press – Either the owner died or they went bankrupt. Perhaps both.
Green Ivy Publishing – 55 “reviews” about them on pissedconsumer.com with $150K in estimated losses.
Helping Hand Literary Services / Janet Kay & Associates / JanGeo Ink / George Harrison Titsworth / Janet Kay Titsworth – The owners were arrested, charged, and sentenced to 10 years probation each. They were also ordered to pay $159 million in restitution.
Llumina Press – The owner, Deborah Greenspan, allegedly closed Llumina (and charged authors for their files), and then opened another firm, Breezeway Books, after numerous complaints were posted about Llumina online. In a press release, they called it “rebranding.” UPDATE 12/27/22: Breezeway Books appears to ALSO now out of business! Good riddance!
Medallion Press – Filed for Chapter 7 bankruptcy on October 17, 2018. “Under a Chapter 7 filing, a trustee will liquidate a company’s assets in order to earn as much money as it can to pay creditors.” Read more HERE.
Mud Luscious Press – Tyler told PW that Mud Luscious books were selling “unexpectedly well” to the point that producing and promoting them was “stealing from the future budget” and creating a “financial shortfall.” Yeah, that doesn’t make any sense to us, either.
Northwest Publishing – The owner faced up to 10 years in prison.
Oyster – This firm “faced competition from Scribd and Amazon.com’s Kindle Unlimited program and an e-book market that has been flat in recent years.”
Paladin Press – Closed at the end of 2017 after 47 years, a few months after the publisher, Peter Lund, died.
Picasso Publishing – The Better Business Bureau issued a complaint about this firm HERE, asking potential victims to contact the Spokane Police Department and the Washington State Attorney General’s Office
Press-Tige Publishing / Martha Ivery, a.k.a. Kelly O’Donnell – Martha Ivery sent me numerous racial and profane comments via email after we exposed her shenanigans on WritersWeekly Whispers and Warnings. She was eventually sentenced to 65 months in prison.
Pronoun – “Sadly, Pronoun has announced that its story ‘ends here,’ leaving a number of authors to wonder what happens to their files.”
Samhain Publishing – “Christina Brashear, publisher of Samhain Publishing, a mostly digital romance publisher, said the publisher will begin to shut down its publishing operations due to a steady decline in e-book sales.”
Servant Publications – “Servant v-p and editorial director Bert Ghezzi told PW that the state of the economy was a key factor in the publisher’s decision to sell its assets.”
Tate Publishing – After claiming to publish 30,000 books, the owners were arrested on several felony charges. While they initially were sending authors copies of their files (and charging extra money for them), it’s been reported that they are no longer responding to emails or letters from authors.
Vantage Press – In a letter to creditors received by Publishers Weekly, law firm Hendel & Collins of Springfield, Mass. writes, “Vantage does not have sufficient revenue to sustain itself as a going concern. It has, therefore, ceased all business operations.”
WinePress Publishing – According to Publishers Weekly, “The house had been plagued in recent years with accusations of fraud, complaints from authors and former employees, and financial problems. WinePress itself had filed a number of lawsuits against its critics and unhappy authors.” Also: “WinePress staff member Malcolm Fraser was convicted on two counts of first-degree child rape and two counts of first-degree molestation of a child. Fraser was a staff member of WinePress Publishing and a pastor of Sound Doctrine Church in Enumclaw, Wash., which owns WinePress.”
How can authors protect themselves?
- If a firm has been sued by an author or supplier, that’s a HUGE red flag. Numerous things have to occur before a lawsuit is filed and any firm that has been sued had plenty of time to rectify those problems. If it was a class-action lawsuit, that’s even worse.
- Avoid new companies. Anybody can slap up a website in a matter of minutes. Avoid doing business with a firm that has published less than 5,000 titles, and that has not been in business for at least 10 years. (Note: BookLocker has been in business for 19 years, and has published more than 9,000 titles.)
- Avoid firms that contact you out of the blue. Bottom feeders are always at risk of going out of business and any firm that spams you after finding you listed as an “author” online should be avoided.
- Avoid doing business with a firm that has changed its name. That is a common tactic companies use to try to distance themselves from previous complaints. The Better Business Bureau will even give a company a brand new, fresh page if they change their name! All previous complaints and even their previous BBB rating, will simply disappear! They also do this if a company simply changes their location.
- Avoid a firm that has been sold, and then sold again, and again. Firms that are frequently being sold to the next hopeful investment firm aren’t showing enough profit to be of value in the original investor’s portfolio. Eventually, the firm won’t have any value, and will be shuttered by the poor shmuck who purchased them last.
- Avoid firms that have multiple complaints posted about them online that follow similar patterns (i.e. unpaid royalties, no or slow responses from the publisher, accusations that the service end of their business ended once the check was cashed, etc.). One, or two, or even a handful of bad reviews, in relation to the number of books that firm has published, is to be expected. And, you should always keep in mind that some disgruntled employees and even competitors can post false negative reviews about a company, including under a variety of names. But, if you are seeing dozens of negative reviews that seem to revolve around similar themes (non-payment of royalties, the publisher ignoring its authors after they paid the initial fees, extreme disorganization, repeated use of the words “scam” and “rip off,” etc.), you should avoid that firm at all costs.
- Avoid firms that have complaints related to taking too long to get a book on the market. Many are in a hurry to get your up-front payment, but aren’t able to provide the services later because they’re swimming in debt, and can’t afford to hire more people. If this occurs, you’ll receive months or years of excuses and your book might never be published.
- Avoid, at all costs, firms that claim all rights to their authors’ production files. This is the one that that will screw you royally if they go under. Good luck getting copies of your files after they stop answering emails and phone calls. Authors should never, ever sign over the rights of their production files to publishers, no matter how good they make that “special deal” look. If an author retains the rights to their production files, they can use those files anywhere they choose if that publisher goes belly-up. If the publisher owns the rights, the authors must start all over again to get their book republished, including paying for new editing, new cover design, and more. See a very short list of publishers that do NOT take all rights HERE.
Do you know of other firms that have gone out of business? Please let us know in the comments section below.
Johnston Press might be in trouble. “Debt and pension woes weigh on publishing firm Johnston Press.”
ANGELA ON TWITTER
ANGELA ON FACEBOOK
ANGELA ON LINKEDIN
Angela is the creator of the Original 24-Hour Short Story Contest!
HAVE A QUESTION ABOUT SELF-PUBLISHING A BOOK?
a self-publishing services company that has been in business since 1998. Ask her anything.