“Why won’t Amazon let my relatives post (fake!) reviews about my new book?”

“Why won’t Amazon let my relatives post (fake!) reviews about my new book?”

Q. –


My book was just published and I asked my family members and a few friends to post reviews on Amazon for it. But, Amazon is rejecting their reviews! Why?!

– S.P.

A. –

Amazon came under fire a few years ago for allowing anyone and everyone to post reviews about books and other products when those individuals had not purchased those products from Amazon.

Amazon later revised their practices to ensure that people posting reviews were real people. You don’t have to buy that particular product from Amazon, nor even prove you purchased it elsewhere. But, in order to post a review on Amazon, you must be a registered Amazon customer with actual purchases in your account.

I agree with Amazon’s policy because there were so many complaints about false reviews, both positive and negative. And, there were stories in the news about companies and authors paying for false reviews. Authors of some books were posting false negative reviews about competing books while others were getting (and even paying) people to post false positive reviews on their own book pages. All of that ultimately hurts the consumer.

In on incident, an ex-neighbor of one of our authors (who had an ongoing feud with the him) posted numerous false negative reviews on the author’s book page on Amazon. Worse, none of the comments he made were about the book itself. They were personal insults aimed at the author and his family. The author complained to Amazon and they didn’t take the reviews down. I have heard many other stories from authors about reviews that were written in a way that made it clear the person never read the book at all.

In the future, ask potential reviewers if they have an Amazon.com account before providing them with a free copy of your book. Ask them to read the book, and give an honest review. Don’t ask people who haven’t even read your book to post false reviews on Amazon. That is fraud.



The Art and Craft of Writing and Editing

Writing is a constant dialogue between author and reader.

Read more here:


7.625 STRATEGIES IN EVERY BEST-SELLER - Revised and Expanded Edition

Acquisition Editor Tam Mossman shares seven essentials every book needs to stay in print, and sell!

Read more here:


Yes, online book promoting can be EASY and FUN! Let us show you how, from Day 1 through Day 90…and beyond!


2 Responses to "“Why won’t Amazon let my relatives post (fake!) reviews about my new book?”"

  1. Dee Arr  May 15, 2018 at 11:06 pm

    There are a number of legitimate ways to finding reviewers, although it has become more difficult now that Amazon has removed emails from reviewer profiles. However, many reviewers also post on GoodReads (a site that is blocking websites…sheesh!) OR they have their own sites. GoodReads also has many reading groups, and some like Authors Needing Reviews provide authors an opportunity to find folks who like to read and review. No matter what, it is a struggle for authors, but a struggle that can be won…provided you have the stamina. Good Luck!

  2. pamelaallegretto  May 11, 2018 at 2:38 pm

    I agree with Amazon’s policy to only allow a verified purchaser to leave a review. I have seen people offer, for a fee, to post 5-star reviews on Amazon. What I don’t like is that someone who purchases a book from Amazon.CA, Amazon.UK. Amazon.IT, Amazon.AU, etc. can post their review on that country’s Amazon account, but it doesn’t automatically show up on the US account, it has to be submitted separately. Whereas, all the Amazon.com reviews, although not added into the review count, show up on the Amazon accounts in various countries. I have had several people who purchased books through different venues try to add their reviews to Amazon, but the reviews were removed. In these cases, I ask them, if they would kindly leave a review on Goodreads. I find Goodreads revues to be quite beneficial.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.